Arbitration Subrogation Specialist - APPLY BY INVITE ONLY

The Arbitration Subrogation Specialist is responsible for the recovery of subrogation claims from insurance carriers and self-insured entities. These claims could also involve multiple tortfeasors. The majority of these claims would be carrier to carrier claims but the incumbent could also work consumer, auto, property and medial/PIP claims if the workload dictates. Responsibilities include working with our clients, insured, claimants, and local and state government offices, appropriately documenting information to achieve recovery of these subrogation claims. If you are hired for a remote/work at home position, we will provide the equipment required to fulfill the role

What you will be doing:

The Arbitration Subrogation Specialist may perform some or all of the duties listed below:

  • Process carrier to carrier subrogation files in varying lines of business including property, restitution and product liability.
  • Review files using a diary system in order to handle correspondence.
  • Respond promptly and professionally to client, insured, carrier requests as well as other incoming calls.
  • Choose course of action with regard to new subrogation files to assure cost effective resolution.
  • Review files for adequacy of investigation and measure of damages to determine whether to pursue arbitration.
  • Prepare and review the initial content of each file while documenting and tracking all ongoing verbal and written correspondence in the SCP & Nuvue systems as well as applicable client systems.
  • Process letters and authority requests.
  • Research the application of laws and statutes as it applies to specific claims in each state.
  • Negotiate adjusted settlements with claimants, carriers and attorneys.
  • Prepare and distribute settlement offer information to client.
  • Assist less experienced Specialists with day to day questions and system restraints.

Arbitration specific responsibilities:

  • Respond professionally and promptly to telephone calls and emails from client brokers, insured, general adjusters, claimants, witnesses, attorneys, and underwriters.
  • Review files using a diary system in order to handle correspondence.
  • Prepare and review the initial applicant Arb, counter and response/counter Arbitrations.
  • Research the application of laws and statutes as it applies to specific claims in each state.
  • Communicate effectively with insured, general adjusters, claimants, witnesses, attorneys, experts and underwriters in order to obtain and or provide necessary information.
  • Determine appropriate claim amounts and review subrogation. Evaluate claims based on information and liability factors.

What you'll get:

  • Full-time. 40 hours per week schedule with overtime opportunities if you'd like
  • Job stability.
  • Training. Extensive paid product and service training.
  • Paid time off.
  • Benefits. Medical, dental and vision insurance with premiums partly paid by the company!
  • College tuition reimbursement.
  • Referral Program. One of the best unlimited employee referral bonus programs out there!
  • Career Growth. Gain great experience to promote to higher roles and leadership training to prepare you for the next step!
  • Annual Performance Reviews. We reward your hard work with annual wage increases!



What you will need:

  • High school diploma or GED, college degree preferred.
  • Five to eight years of proven subrogation or claims experience that includes substantial exposure to carrier to carrier claims is preferred.
  • Three to five years previous Arbitration writing experience is preferred
  • Ability to type 30 WPM with 85% accuracy.
  • Appraisal certification may be required.
  • Ability to work independently.
  • Successful completion of relevant insurance industry courses strongly preferred.
  • Property, medical pay and workers compensation experience is preferred
  • Strong analyzing and negotiating techniques.
  • Excellent organizational and time-management skills.
  • Responds to internal and external requests in a timely manner and works to deliver quality service. Consistently demonstrates accuracy and attention to detail.
  • Communicates clearly and logically using appropriate written and oral techniques Seeks clarification for unclear or missing information.
  • Demonstrated reasoning and problem solving abilities.
  • Ability to build and maintain relationships.
  • Work with sense of urgency.
  • Demonstrates a sincere interest in listening to and responding to customer concerns and solving their issue in a timely manner.
  • The ability to work independently and interact well within a team environment.


Referral Program

Did you know we have one of the most lucrative referral programs around? Here's how it works:
For more info on our Buddy Bucks Referral Program, watch this video:

Looking for a fun place where you can fit in, fuel your passions, help people, and take charge of your career? You’re in the right place. Join the Afni family and be part of our talented global team passionate about helping people and pursuing the life we dream about.

Do Your Best Work and Grow Your Career

When you join Afni, we'll instantly make you part of our global family of friendly people focused on making really good customer experiences happen. If you're like us, you want to belong to something special, have meaningful work to do, and know how to achieve your career and life goals.

Our award-winning training and development programs get you ready to work and grow. If you’re the kind of person who wants to build a career and learn new things, we’ll provide the path and the tools to get you there. You bring the motivation and commitment.

Work in and Support the Bloomington-Normal Community

Are you the kind of person who loves to get involved in community events and non-profit organizations? We love it and make it a habit to respond to the needs of the Bloomington-Normal community through fund raisers, community events, and other service opportunities.

When you work here, you’ll have plenty of chances to get involved. In Bloomington-Normal, we regularly support the United Way, Big Brothers and Big Sisters, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Easter Seals, American Heart Association, CISAR Animal Shelter, and more.

Our Location

1310 Martin Luther King Jr Dr, Bloomington, IL 61701

See it on a map and get driving directions.


"One of my favorite moments was when the leadership team asked me to join a different department. I was able to prove to myself that I can take on any challenge, do the work required to advance, and conquer anything I put my mind to."

BRANDON, Bloomington Illinois

"My shyness has been replaced with confidence as I’ve learned and developed here. Now I can talk to pretty much anyone and can handle a lot of different situations in and outside of work."

ABIGAIL, Tucson Arizona

The Perks

Incentives + Bonus
Competitive Pay
Dress for Your Day
Paid Time Off
Tuition Reimbursement
Full-time Schedules
Fun Events
Referral Bonus